Cornwall Council ignores widespread opposition to NHS dismantlement

After a 5,000 strong petition demanding the council rejects the changes to the NHS in Cornwall and that a referendum take place on the issue was essentially chucked out today in Cornwall Council’s general meeting.

Fourteen hospitals in the county are going to be turned into businesses (‘Community Interest Companies’) instead of remaining within the national framework. If this doesn’t equate to the partial privatisation of the NHS I’m not quite sure what does. 2,400 staff will be handed over to these private bodies – which could limit collective bargaining rights and will certainly affect pay and conditions.

It’s unclear how much thought has gone into the decision to act as lackies for the Con-Dem government. The impact assessment, which can be found on the council website (hidden away, of course), demands the expected benefits of the changes be outlined. The council’s response is

“Transformed delivery of community health care in Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly”

Transformed how? Surely this is much too vague considering the scale of the changes? An ambiguous one line statement doesn’t equate to a full impact assessment, or at least it shouldn’t.

Moreover, the list of groups consulted about the changes is near farcical. Not one union is officially listed in the impact assessment, though apparently some unions were consulted at a different point and acquiesced against the policies of national leadership, instead of opposing the changes outright. The groups consulted include ‘Perfect Moment an apparently charitable group but whose site immediately declares it’s aim is Business & Project Development’ and ‘TR14ers Community Dance Team‘. A dance team? Consulted about drastic changes to health care affecting thousands of people? First as tragedy, then as farce…

Jude Robinson (the Labour councillor) and some Independents and Lib Dems opposed the moves. But perhaps there can be future challenges to the changes – legal, protest-based or union-coordinated.

There’ll be a lot more opposition to the NHS ‘reforms’ to come in Cornwall. A Save our NHS group has been formed and Cornwall Anti-Cuts Alliance will be actively campaigning about the £20bn NHS cuts.

Meanwhile, there could be some positive news on the horizon. Apparently 12-22 councillors are thinking of ousting Tory leader Alec Robertson as head of CCC, in favour of Truro Trehaverne (my ward, incidentally) councillor Fiona Ferguson. She’s still right-wing, but if Robertson were to be ousted it would destabilise the council’s Tory/Independent coalition.




  1. ‘Frank Dobson in Camborne’

    Please watch my 2 minute video of Frank Dobson when he came to meet Labour members and to present our NHS petition

    I attended the Council Meeting and the outcome was very disappointing, but the petition succeeded in forcing at least a debate and Council members will be held responsible where they failed to reject the plans the PCT seem to want, to break up the NHS and leave the community hospitals to slide into the hands of private health companies.

    What can we do now? Its the strategic health authority who will make the decision, so contact them with your views.

  2. I think it should be noted that ALL of the Mebyon Kernow councillors including myself opposed the moves not just Jude and a couple of independents we have been steadfast in our opposition to the cuts and the creeping privatisation of public services

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s